Challenging the Notion of "Survival of the Boring" in Evolution
Written on
Chapter 1: The Misconception of Boring Survival
The phrase “survival of the boring” refers to a long-standing belief that evolution tends to favor ordinary, adaptable species instead of those showcasing innovation. Recent research, however, contests this idea, suggesting that diversity and creativity are key factors in evolutionary advancement.
While not everyone appreciates raccoons, I've always found them fascinating. They can become a nuisance—especially when I forget to secure my compost bin on trash day. Yet, their cleverness, resourcefulness, and adaptability in urban settings are qualities I admire.
Naturally, this view isn't shared by everyone. Those who have had raccoons invade their attics or chimneys likely don't share my enthusiasm for these omnivorous creatures.
Section 1.1: Evolution and Generalist Species
Traditionally, it is believed that raccoons exemplify the generalist species favored by evolution, adhering to the concept of “survival of the boring.” For years, ecologists have maintained that mammals capable of consuming a variety of foods and thriving in diverse habitats are the ones that endure challenging times.
Dr. Ken Angielczyk, a paleobiologist, has spent the last twenty years exploring evolution through statistical methods, focusing on how ancient ecosystems functioned and how mass extinctions impacted various mammal species. He currently serves as the MacArthur Curator of Paleomammalogy and leads a section at Chicago's Field Museum, a renowned institution dedicated to research and conservation.
Subsection 1.1.1: Insights from Recent Research
This week, Nature Ecology published a study led by Dr. Angielczyk, which examined the family trees of mammal species during several mass extinction events. The findings revealed that the species that tend to survive are not necessarily the unremarkable ones; rather, it is often those exhibiting novel traits that thrive after disasters.
“The idea of ‘survival of the unspecialized’ has been around since the 1800s, positing that generalized animals are less likely to go extinct,” Dr. Angielczyk notes. “However, our research indicates that those which survived often appeared generalized only in retrospect, when compared to their later descendants.”
Section 1.2: Innovation Over Generalization
Upon reviewing the family trees, researchers discovered that many enduring animal species were, in fact, quite innovative, rather than dull. “They were advanced for their era, possessing new traits that may have contributed to their survival and adaptability,” Dr. Angielczyk remarked.
The family tree utilized in this study was compiled by Professor Spencer Hellert from Columbia College, who also collaborates with the Field Museum. He assembled one of the largest fossil trees illustrating the lineage of synapsids, a diverse group of ancient animals from which modern mammals descend.
Chapter 2: The Role of Mass Extinctions in Evolutionary Change
The first video, titled "Evolution is not survival of the fittest," delves into how traditional views of evolution might be misleading, emphasizing the importance of diversity and innovation rather than mere survival.
The second video, "Natural Selection - Crash Course Biology #14," offers an engaging overview of natural selection and its role in shaping species over time, reinforcing the idea that adaptability is crucial for survival.
Mass extinctions often trigger periods of rapid diversification known as evolutionary radiations. Contrary to previous beliefs that these radiations favor generalist species, the data suggests that larger synapsids that were not simply generalist insect-eaters frequently flourished during these critical times.
Some species that might seem mundane today were groundbreaking upon their introduction. For example, mammals with grinding teeth adapted effectively to food shortages, showcasing their capability to thrive amidst scarcity.
And Another Thing…
This enhanced understanding of evolutionary processes is vital for us to comprehend our own existence in the world. Acknowledging that diversity and innovation are fundamental to survival can inspire us to nurture these qualities in our relationships.
I have always believed that “normal is just a synonym for average,” and I often ponder, “Why settle for boring?”
“We still lack clarity regarding whether there’s a consistent set of traits typically found in the ancestors of evolutionary diversifications,” Dr. Angielczyk concluded. “The complexity we observe in mammalian diversifications indicates a need to explore other groups to determine if this phenomenon is unique to mammals or a broader trend.”
The quest for knowledge is endless if we are willing to explore.
Learn more:
Survival of the Newest
Derived faunivores are the forerunners of major synapsid radiations
Beaver Fossil Sheds Light on Mammal Evolution
Animal Origins Revealed by Rethinking Fossil Record
Bird Evolution Can Be Surprisingly Fast
I’m a freelance writer and blogger, providing content services to select business clients. My extensive experience in content creation, technical writing, and training has allowed me to work with many of Canada’s leading organizations. Specialties include Content Marketing, Social Media, Technical Writing, and Training Development. View all posts by David Morton Rintoul
Originally published at http://daretoknow.ca on October 13, 2023.