Understanding the Hearing Voices Approach: A Compassionate Perspective
Written on
Chapter 1: The Nature of Hearing Voices
Discussing challenging topics can be done without causing harm; for instance, one can inquire about suicidal thoughts without triggering them. However, the question remains: why is there such reluctance to address the phenomenon of hearing voices?
Experiencing auditory or visual phenomena doesn't inherently indicate schizophrenia. Such experiences can occur in various contexts, including Bipolar Disorder, Major Depression, PTSD, drug use, or even in individuals with no mental health diagnosis. The key distinction lies in whether someone has sought psychiatric help. Why does Western society harbor such fear of voices? If scientists dismiss the 'woo' in paranormal claims, why do these notions persist in scientific discussions and societal stigmas?
Experiencing sights and sounds is subjective. Research shows that our experiences are rarely perfectly aligned; even a group of witnesses to an event may have varied accounts. If a person who hears voices encounters someone who is deaf or blind, the latter might view them as delusional, yet the reality is that these auditory and visual experiences are simply part of human perception. While it's ideal for witnesses to share a consensus, the reality is that both victims and survivors can emerge from the same event, shaped by their individual perspectives.
All experiences are filtered through our bodies, processed by the brain, and then interpreted by our conscious minds. How we choose to respond to these experiences influences whether our brains amplify or suppress the information. Interestingly, one doesn't need to consciously register every piece of data; for example, product placements in advertising can lead to unconscious purchases, highlighting how our unconscious responses are manipulated. This phenomenon is exploited by casinos and smartphones, showing how easily we can be influenced.
Some individuals perceive things that others do not, and this does not imply that they are unwell. Instead, it indicates they are experiencing life differently. Each experience carries context, which can either alleviate or intensify symptoms. Without symptoms, a mental health diagnosis cannot be established.
Contextual experiences can be induced without substances, as practices like meditation or rituals can encourage such occurrences. Therefore, merely hearing or seeing things is not a mental health issue; how we respond to these sensations matters. For instance, if someone identifies as a medium who sees and hears spirits yet maintains a stable job and family life, they are functioning well. Conversely, when an individual's ability to function deteriorates across various aspects of life, it may signal a need for clinical evaluation.
Chapter 2: The Intersection of Mental Health and Perception
The first video, "Beyond Possible: How the Hearing Voices Approach Transforms Lives," discusses how understanding the experiences of those who hear voices can lead to transformative healing and greater empathy.
The experiences of hearing voices can sometimes signify a special sensitivity or a mental health challenge, such as Major Depression, Bipolar Disorder, or PTSD. Substance use, particularly cannabis, may also contribute to auditory and visual phenomena. The humorous portrayals in media often reflect these complexities, as cannabis can lead to both hallucinations and moments of intense clarity.
If someone is diagnosed with bipolar disorder and uses cannabis, it raises questions about the origins of their symptoms—whether they stem from the disorder itself or the substance use. The interplay between these elements complicates diagnosis and treatment. While cannabis may help with irritability and sleep, which in turn can reduce hallucinations, it’s essential to weigh the benefits and drawbacks carefully.
Every experience has its positives and negatives. For instance, if a deceased loved one appears in a comforting manner, few would wish to lose that connection. Most who seek mental health support are those experiencing distressing encounters, such as terrifying visions.
Experiencing hyperacusis—heightened sensitivity to sound—should not be confused with hallucinations. Our brains can access various data points, and our consciousness can amplify certain sounds, leading to perceptions that others might not share. This ability illustrates the continuum of experiences, where some individuals manage their perceptions well while others may struggle significantly.
Mental health conditions, while sometimes presenting challenges, can also lead to remarkable achievements, as demonstrated in films like "A Beautiful Mind," where a character's struggles ultimately led to significant contributions to academia. However, it’s crucial to recognize that not everyone has the same level of insight or rationality regarding their experiences.
The societal approach towards medications should prioritize enhancing social functionality rather than merely sedating individuals. Some may require medication, while others might thrive through community support and understanding. The push to eliminate institutional settings often overlooked the necessity for accessible mental health clinics, leading to gaps in care.
Are we open to the possibility of spirits? When grieving, hearing a loved one’s voice might simply be a manifestation of memory or a deeper connection beyond life. These experiences may serve as reminders of our emotional ties, and perhaps, by examining them with empathy rather than judgment, we can foster greater understanding.
Mental health challenges, such as depression, may reflect the brain’s process of sorting through emotional pain. Emotions guide us, helping to navigate life’s complexities. Symptoms are not inherently negative; they signal where attention is needed.
Merely hearing or seeing things should not be labeled as pathological. If someone has a mental health concern, it might indicate they are processing emotional distress. Pain, while uncomfortable, is a natural part of human existence that encourages growth and self-awareness. Ignoring symptoms often leads to exacerbation, while addressing them can foster healing.
Ultimately, achieving optimal health requires a balanced approach—recognizing that life will inherently present challenges. Awareness and kindness towards one another can pave the way for a more compassionate society.
With love, John
Recommended Resources:
The second video, "Hearing Voices: The Movement That Encourages You to Talk to Your Voices," explores how discussing these experiences openly can help break down stigma and promote healing.
Psychologists Suggesting Spirits are Real
The Presence of Other Worlds: The Psychological and Spiritual Findings on Emanuel Swedenborg, by Wilson Van Dusen.